Do Binaural Beats Actually Entrain the Mind? Dr. Elizabeth Krasnoff Talks with iAwake

Dr. Elizabeth Krasnoff, Ph.D. talks with iAwake concerning the neurophysiology of brainwave entrainment, what binaural beats truly do, the function of protocol, pink noise, therapeutic with sound, and far more on this fascinating, complete, behind-the-scenes-of-sound-technology interview. Dr. Krasnoff wrote her 2021 dissertation on “The Results of Auditory Binaural Beats on Consciousness and the Human Nervous System” based mostly on essentially the most present scientific analysis, and is right here to share her ardour about sound – the way it works and the way it can heal. What does the most recent analysis present? Do the results of binaural beats stay as much as the advertising and marketing claims made about them? Can they be transformative? Discover out right here.

Do Binaural Beats Actually Entrain the Mind?

• What led Elizabeth to finding out binaural beats at first? 1:55
• It’s not entrainment. It’s a frequency following response. 7:48
• Can sound heal nerve harm? 11:18
• Binaural beats, rhythms, and the autonomic nervous system 12:22
• Sound location — the place binaural beats are processed within the mind — is a major survival talent. 16:18
• What about provider frequencies? 21:18
• What are a few of the research doing fallacious? 25:41
• Binaural beats and the reticular activating system 31:39
• The function of protocol with binaural beats 33:59
• Modeling binaural beats after the goal wave form 45:30
• How resonance creates further vitality for the mind 47:43
• Binaural beats synchronize your mind hemispheres. 55:03
• Mixing frequencies works finest. 57:35

Elizabeth Krasnoff Talks with iAwake

Full transcript, studying time roughly 35 minutes.

Take heed to iAwake’s Excessive Focus audio observe from our Stealing Move+ suite that will help you focus and course of the data when you learn this transcript. The transcript will take round 35 minutes to learn, so this 25-minute observe has been set to loop. Please put on good high quality headphones or earbuds for one of the best expertise.

---

John: Welcome, everybody. How are you? Right here we’re, and let me introduce us. My title is John Dupuy. You could or could not know me, however I’m the CEO of iAwake Applied sciences. And I don’t know all of what Heidi does at iAwake — she’s my assistant, however she does much more than that, and he or she’s right here for this interview as a result of she ought to be. And that is Douglas Prater. He’s certainly one of our essential individuals at iAwake; he creates the know-how. He’s an exquisite artist, an exquisite soul, and has an amazing scientific thoughts that understands the interior workings of this science and know-how and what we do. And that is Dr. Elizabeth Krasnoff. She did her Ph.D. opus magnum on mind entrainment know-how, so we’re right here to select her mind and see what she’s discovered and what she will share about what she discovered on this journey to change into a… Physician of Psychology, I suppose, proper, you’re a psychologist now?

Elizabeth: Truly, I’m a Physician of Transformation.

John: Oh, how cool is that?

Elizabeth: I’m within the College of Transformation and Consciousness.

John: …At CIIS (California Institute of Integral Research). It’s an exquisite faculty. It’s produced all types of good individuals and had nice lecturers there over the a long time. I’ve been related with it. So congratulations on that.

Elizabeth: Thanks, John. Nice journey.

John: So, Heidi, you introduced a pair or three questions. You wish to lead off?

Heidi: Effectively, I’ll lead off with the primary one. I simply puzzled what drew you in direction of finding out brainwave entrainment at first?

Elizabeth: I’m half deaf. I’ve tinnitus, I’ve misophonia, and as a baby, I had profound social isolation. I didn’t know I used to be deaf till I used to be 19 as a result of it’s a half deafness. Once I was 19 and I went to, lastly, the emergency room as a result of the tinnitus was so loud, I couldn’t sleep, they stated, nicely, it’s since you’re deaf. And I stated, that’s very humorous. Actually, what’s occurring? I used to be deaf! And so I received my first pair of listening to aids.

John: Sensible. So if we’re in an elevator in New York, and we’ve like 80 flooring to go, how would you summarize what you present in your dissertation? After which we will construct on no matter you say after that.

Elizabeth: Certain factor. I’m fairly detailed, so, I’m going to time myself right here, simply two minutes, proper? Okay. I wish to get into the small print!

John: Let’s take three, Elizabeth.

Elizabeth: Okay. The analysis: I like evidence-based therapeutic. I’m an intuitive, I’ve skilled as an intuitive, I do know the ability of that, and I additionally know the ability that comes from realizing the information. They inform one another. The instinct can inform us what to search for or the right way to use issues that we discovered with information, and the information can inform us, did it work and what ought to we additional discover? So, what did I discover? Effectively, I needed to look into all of the advertising and marketing claims. I’ve a apply; my apply known as Sound Medicine. It’s seven years outdated. I exploit instinct, I exploit sound, particularly binaural beats, however a lot of modalities. I exploit shamanic instruments, and I exploit biofeedback within the type of HeartMath. I’m licensed in all of these modalities. And every of them dropped at my understanding an consciousness that the nervous system is a rhythm.

Elizabeth: So I needed to ask, nicely, if we will’t, in mainstream science, hint these vitality pathways but, what can we all know? We are able to research the nervous system. And I stated, I wish to convey some science, some strong science and proof to the sound therapeutic area a couple of sound know-how. And I selected binaural beats. I structured my evaluate on twenty-six research. These research needed to be in respected, peer-reviewed journals, and so they needed to be within the final six years, and so they needed to have at the least reported 12 of the 18 information factors that I in contrast. My questions centered on: Can we measure the impact on our neural mind waves, of the 5 mind states that we’ve all come to measure? Gamma, subsequent is beta, alpha, theta, and delta. Can we measure that and see binaural beats having an impact on these neural rhythms, and might we measure the autonomic nervous system and see if binaural beats is having an impact on the autonomic nervous system? And it turned out we completely can measure these issues.

It’s not entrainment. It’s a frequency following response.

Elizabeth: Okay, so let me simply go over right here for a second. About midway by way of my analysis, I actually began to grasp that each one of those research authors and the first researchers within the area, who’re Dr. Gerald Oster, a physicist who printed in Scientific American in 1973 and began the up to date exploration of binaural beats, and F. Holmes Atwater, the previous director of the Monroe Institute, of the analysis there — so each the first area researchers and all my 26 research stated, this isn’t entrainment. We simply all use that phrase, and a mechanism is occurring, however it’s not entrainment.

Elizabeth: So, by the best way, rhythm and sound clearly entrain the mind. There are necessary scientific research that set up that and there are various therapeutic approaches, together with neurologic music remedy, very nicely revered, evidence-based music remedy applied sciences, that use rhythm. That’s not a query. Rhythm entrains the mind. In my world, we name that monaural beats. Monaural beats is when the envelope of sound is full earlier than it hits your ears, okay? That clearly entrains the mind. However with binaural beats, one thing totally different is occurring right here. I got here throughout this and I stated, nicely, there goes my dissertation! It’s not entrainment; I don’t have anything to say right here. After which I noticed, wait a minute, no, that is actually necessary, as a result of what’s it?

Elizabeth: So these two researchers that I spoke about and the twenty-six research all stated, okay, what we’re seeing is a frequency following response. We’re all recording very clearly a frequency following response. It’s simply not sufficient vitality that will point out entrainment. It’s one thing else. So I appeared on the different hypotheses, and the one which I align with was actually put ahead by Atwater. For those who go deep into the science, the correlation is so full, I believe that’s the path for the analysis to take. The speculation is that that binaural beat is coming into your reticular activating system, which is a neural community within the brainstem and a non-primary listening to pathway. One thing else is occurring there.

John: Does that imply individuals with listening to issues can use this know-how? And successfully?

Elizabeth: What listening to issues?

John: Yeah, that’s a query. I don’t know. I’ve had that query given to me so much, and anecdotally what individuals say is, yeah, it appears to work. So, I used to be simply throwing it out to you from what you initially stated about your deafness and this know-how, whether or not you have been being affected by it. And I didn’t imply to interrupt you since you have been in such an amazing useless, it’s great.

Can sound heal nerve harm?

Elizabeth: Under no circumstances. We’ll get to all of it. Listening to loss like I’ve is nerve harm. One of many six research that didn’t work was attempting to make use of binaural beats to heal tinnitus. So what do I find out about that? I do know some private expertise after which some analysis. I believe the simplest remedy for tinnitus I do know is occurring proper right here at UCSF, (I’m in San Francisco). They may match the frequencies and hit you again with these frequencies, these very excessive frequencies that match your tinnitus pitch. I’ve learn superb issues about that therapeutic know-how. However I’m a bit inquisitive about this, as a result of I simply got here off of a sound, mind, and vibration convention the place I offered — it was truly on binaural beats. The query there’s, can sound heal nerve harm?

Binaural beats, rhythms, and the autonomic nervous system

Elizabeth: The way in which I exploit sound and a lot of the proof I discover is that sound, significantly binaural beats, can work to heal rhythms that the nervous system is liable for. Rhythms. So what’s an instance of that? Your cardiovascular system is a rhythm. Your endocrine, your hormonal system is a rhythm. Actually something that the autonomic nervous system or the hypothalamus or the nervous system controls is a rhythm. We have now a circadian rhythm, we’ve ultradian rhythms, that’s rhythms that occur in beneath a 24-hour time interval. All of these issues that the autonomic nervous system and the hypothalamus deal with are issues you may deal with with binaural beats. We’ve sort of outlined that. So again to a type of threads, can we are saying that the advertising and marketing claims are true? Effectively, these research confirmed that conclusively (I don’t have the slide in entrance of me) that sleep is positively affected by binaural beats. Stress is positively affected by binaural beats. And by the best way, the Stress Institute of America stated one thing like 90 % of our sickness comes from our stressors — our response to our stressors in our life.

John: Together with dependancy, which I don’t assume they have been speaking about, you understand.

Elizabeth: That was not talked about. So my HeartMath background actually dialed me in on what stress is, what it does, and the right way to work with it. In my enterprise, I assist shoppers scale back their stressors and discover wholesome rhythms. So let’s see, again to our listing. Stress, the notion of ache. Binaural beats have been demonstrated to be an analgesic. Much less ache remedy is required. Dentists will check that. There are three fields that there are binaural analysis in proper now: neuroscience, psychology (significantly cognitive psychology, in fact), and well being. So all the quantitative measurements are sort of coming from neuroscience, all of the qualitative, semi-quantitative sort of come from the sphere of psychology, however actually all three fields are trying in all these instructions to see what are the results. So we’ve named sleep, we’ve named stress, we’ve named ache, meditation, and trance. That’s documented. Meditation and trance. Cognitive duties, like reminiscence and focus, that’s documented. And all of these items are rhythmic of their nature. Doesn’t look like it. But when we took a deep dive with that, it could shortly make sense.

Elizabeth: So these are the issues that at this second in time have been clinically documented to be positively affected by binaural beats. So we will go two locations — we will go, why are there six research that didn’t present any impact? And we might additionally briefly have a look at nerve harm. At that convention I used to be simply in, lots of people are on the frontier of many various therapeutic areas, and nerve harm is certainly one of them. Utilizing sound, utilizing ultrasound, utilizing particular frequencies. However I wish to make the excellence that these are all monaural sounds. The sound envelope is full earlier than it hits the mind.

Sound location — the place binaural beats are processed within the mind — is a major survival talent.

Elizabeth: We’re in one other realm, we’re in binaural beats, not entrainment, the sound envelope isn’t full. It’s completed inside our mind. I wish to discuss Oster for one second right here. He had three key insights. Let’s see if I can keep in mind all of them. One among them was that we’ve in our mind an auditory pathway for sound location that’s the similar place that binaural beats are processed. So what he stated to us was that it is a perform of our mind and a major survival talent. Within the fetus, the very first thing you get is your listening to. When you’re out and about and attempting to remain alive on this planet, your means to outlive relies on your means to decode all of those thousands and thousands of invisible vibrations which can be coming at you. That’s what that is. It’s a decoder. And you might be creating your actuality in each second. (David Eagleman on the mind, if you need a deep dive into that. He’s good.)

Elizabeth: So with sound, that binaural listening to that may be a perform of our mind solely exists momentarily in nature, since you don’t have these prolonged moments of that phasing, okay? Once we create binaural beats, we’re creating them synthetically. We’re activating that system. In order that ought to be sufficient proof proper there for anybody. However it’s not. I digress. So what occurs is, we create that prolonged binaural beat. We’re opening new portals of enlargement, of therapeutic, of risk within the mind that as people we by no means had obtainable to us earlier than, undertaking issues that take a long time for meditators to perform. And we’re utilizing a system that naturally exists.

Heidi: You’re saying nature has these little tiny therapeutic moments, however it’s with sound?

Elizabeth: They’re not therapeutic moments. They’re finding moments.

John: And therefore survival potential.

Elizabeth: Within the mind, the factor that’s activated proper after sound within the auditory cortex is the motor cortex. I hear and I flip my head. Do I must run? That’s how the method goes. Sound location is crucial to our survival and that’s the place that we’re working with once we are utilizing binaural beats. That was Oster’s first discovery to us. And I believe that’s crucial. He additionally observed that it doesn’t deteriorate with age. Very attention-grabbing. You don’t truly must understand binaural beats to obtain binaural beats. There are two research that doc that. The way in which they did it’s they might have the excessive frequency within the auditory vary and the low frequency out of the auditory vary, and the impact would nonetheless occur. I see, sure, the artist…

Doug: I’m pondering by way of so many various prospects right here. So was the frequency that was subsonic lower than 20 Hz or so?

Elizabeth: It has to have been, as a result of that’s the underside shelf of our listening to vary. However for the particular information on that, it’s within the Oster article, the 1973 article. I’m additionally making my dissertation obtainable open supply.

Doug: Great. Extra individuals ought to do this.

Elizabeth: Sure! And I’ve all my references. So what I’m going to offer you in the present day is what I’ve reviewed as a researcher. Something I say that you really want extra details about, I can level you to a research or a researcher. For those who cease me and ask for a reputation, I can do this. That’s actually necessary to me. I do wish to additionally make intuitive leaps and understandings, however I like to border that, and say it is a guess versus that is what the information has proven. I believe it’s necessary.

What about provider frequencies? 

Doug: One of many questions that I had for you pertains to what we have been simply speaking about with being out of the audible vary. I additionally noticed in your analysis that one of many components that was not standardized all through the research was the provider frequency. And I puzzled for those who had any suggestions for that, for those who have been capable of verify or refute the speculation that decrease provider frequencies are extra highly effective for, I assume not entrainment, however the frequency following results of binaural beats. And for those who had any suggestions for the place that normal could also be.

Elizabeth: Sure. I want I had extra concrete information for you. So 18 information factors, provider frequency clearly an enormous information level. And we’re in the beginning of data on that information level. I can consider possibly three references the place I noticed a research the place authors say, we chosen this provider frequency as a result of it creates this impact. Everyone else is just about blind to provider frequency at this level. However there are just a few authors that I can level you to which have begun that analysis and use particular frequency for particular causes. I used to be listening very fastidiously on the final sound convention as a result of one of many points that the sound therapeutic area faces is a scarcity of validation concerning the sound frequencies that individuals use. The place did that data come from? Have you ever critically trialed these frequencies?

Elizabeth: There are a pair individuals on the market working with some very particular frequencies proper now. No, this isn’t binaural beats. That is simply frequency remedy. And lots of people are utilizing 40 Hz for irritation and another advantages. They usually know what frequency is nice for therapeutic nerves and what frequency is nice for these numerous stress or abdomen points. They usually combine them. So what I discover attention-grabbing there’s, are these are provider frequencies? What for those who’re focusing on nerve harm and you employ a provider frequency that’s recognized to heal nerve harm and add the binaural beat to it? Wow. I can offer you that listing of frequencies. Completely. That is all of the Globe Institute, the sound therapeutic heart right here in San Francisco. They’re doing a unbelievable job of unifying the sphere and the analysis. I additionally assume that… So tuning forks is a really well-established area and they’re dialed into a really particular set of frequencies as nicely. I hope {that a} researcher goes in there and says, okay, you consider these frequencies do these items. Let’s go into the lab. Let’s see precisely.

Doug: I’d like to see that. There positively appears to be lots of generally accepted or repeated knowledge that individuals discuss, the Solfeggio frequencies, for instance. And I’d like to see research’ validation or not.

Elizabeth: Sure. So if anybody’s listening, I at all times say, at this second, you need to belief the best way you are feeling and the best way you reply, as a result of there is no such thing as a information to help this for the time being, which doesn’t imply there gained’t be. In order that’s so far as I’ve gotten with the provider frequencies. Length turned an enormous factor: a minimal of eight to 10 minutes. And there are lots of very particular research — these are EEG research, they’re not subjective. It’s not like, “oh, I really feel higher now.” They’re EEG research. And the superb research will correlate EEG research with subjective assessments like a BRUMS temper check, and even only a subjective diary. And while you do this, you may — I’m pondering of three research particularly — see individuals reporting what you might be marking on the EEG, which is a extremely good affirmation. So length was essential. Service frequency we’re starting to find out about.

What are a few of the research doing fallacious?

Elizabeth: I wish to discuss intra particular person variations and now Oster’s third level as nicely. So, keep in mind how we stated binaural beats impacts the nervous system, which is a rhythm? He observed that binaural beats have an effect on or generally is a instrument for measuring the endocrine system. As a result of girls, at totally different occasions of the month, based mostly on their hormonal cycle, responded otherwise to the identical binaural beat. Fairly fascinating. However it is sensible if you concentrate on it when it comes to a rhythm. So, what I wish to say right here is while you’re establishing a research…there’s one research that he couldn’t get outcomes and so they had twenty 50-year-old girls on the similar provider frequency.

Elizabeth: What if the provider frequency they selected and the binaural beat that they chose doesn’t affect menopausal girls? At age 50, your endocrine system is in a distinct place as a girl, so lots of the research, they might be too restricted. They wouldn’t have the right…that is of those that didn’t work. They wouldn’t have sufficient individuals within the research and they’d have too many individuals in the identical class. On research the place you’re dividing and your hiring half male and half feminine and also you’re having a large age vary, you’re getting a greater learn. That’s one of many components: age and gender. And there’s a 3rd inter particular person distinction that we find out about, and I’m pointing to a selected research, Redick is the writer, and what she measured was our eyeblink charges. Measuring eyeblink charges tells you about your dopamine ranges, and measuring the dopamine ranges tells you whether or not somebody has the introverted persona or an extroverted persona. Fairly fascinating. So what she discovered was that for those who have been an introverted persona, you have been extra affected by binaural beats. So when you’ve got…like in a few of these research, there’s 9 topics, and so they say, “oh, we didn’t get any outcomes.” Did you’ve got 9 introverted individuals? A few of these research, they solely used three minutes of binaural beats. A giant one which received lots of press.

John: That’s proper. I do not forget that.

Elizabeth: Three minutes! And have you learnt what else that research concluded? Okay, I’ll inform you two actually enjoyable info. That research additionally concluded that monaural beats (we all know what monaural beats are — that’s common sound) and binaural beats don’t have any measurable impact on our moods. None. I’m like, wait a minute, you simply stated that sound has no impact on human moods. I don’t know if anyone would agree with that!

John: Ever hear of the Beatles?

Elizabeth: Precisely! However see, the factor is, I don’t have a look at these research nearly as good guys or unhealthy guys. These are individuals truthfully looking for solutions. They’re asking sincere questions. They’re establishing the research to one of the best of their skills and so they’re seeking to outline the parameters. They usually did outline parameters. That specific research can also be certainly one of my prime research for documenting cross-frequency communication. That’s hemispheric synchronization, which is without doubt one of the different advertising and marketing claims. Can it synchronize our mind hemispheres? That research outlined it very clearly.

Elizabeth: So, you understand we as a society fall right into a sample of pondering that we perceive one thing by a quick learn or making a conclusion. There was a few of that happening, a few of inter particular person variations not being taken under consideration, not sufficient length, selecting the fallacious binaural beat for the fallacious activity. One research used theta binaural beats to create a cognitive focus. That’s not what it’s for, proper? For a cognitive focus, you’d use gamma or gamma/beta. Let’s discuss that for a second. The issues that we will actually perceive and our developer can inform us, in all probability, if he has used these ones, the issues that we will actually see occurring are gamma and beta pulling us into focus.

Elizabeth: Proper? That’s what I exploit once I’m studying my neuroscience research and dropping my thoughts, attempting to grasp. I’ll use the gamma, the gamma/beta. I’ve utilized in my apply theta for my 13-year-old youngsters which can be ADD. One youngster discovered his soccer performs that manner. So, something focusing or excessive gear is up there, and then you definitely’re actually coming down the gearbox. We’ve all pushed a automobile — then you definitely come right down to the center ones and now you’re beginning to do meditative: alpha, theta, after which sleep — delta. I like alpha/theta. I like theta. AndI haven’t discovered the delta that works for me but. I like a low voice, a human voice. I’ll hear to love Headspace, Andy, studying or one thing. A male voice could be very soothing for me personally. I like these low timbres.

Binaural beats and the reticular activating system

Elizabeth: So, to go over to the reticular activating system…We all know that binaural beats come within the auditory canals, two separate frequencies, and we all know that they meet, as a result of they put electrodes on the brains of cats and different little animals. We all know that the olivary nuclei is the place they’re begun to be processed, and we all know that they find yourself on the auditory cortex. That is the place we hear, the auditory cortex, not in our ear.

Elizabeth: What occurs within the center? The speculation is that it’s the RAS system. The RAS, I observe, has three states, and within the area of neuroscience, that’s thought of the gateway for consciousness. That is the place consciousness is available in — you may’t research sound with out finding out consciousness. It has awake, meditative/gentle/sleep/dozy, after which it has deep sleep. These are our three states of consciousness that the RAS system regulates. And it’s thought of the gateway to consciousness in that area. That’s the recognized science, the precise definition. As a result of the RAS creates our awakening to our surroundings. It processes exterior processes, all 5 senses, not simply sound. That is recognized science, and it processes our inside perceptions as nicely. So all of our inside and exterior perceptions go in there. And it regulates our rising consciousness of the environment, inside and exterior. Can we awake to it or will we retreat from it? Isn’t that mainly the 5 mind states that we’re finding out? From the excessive gear to the low gear? So I’m saying the proof is so compelling, that’s received to be the following factor {that a} researcher cracks and that’s the way you along with your beats are impacting states of consciousness.

The function of protocol with binaural beats

Elizabeth: What else? One different enormous issue that I discovered from this research — you’re going to like this one, and this can be one thing that you just already do as an organization or one thing that you could start to develop — is protocol. What occurs earlier than you employ the binaural beats? So I stated binaural beats are one thing else? A speculation that I shaped which has been rejected within the area — I wish to be clear, and a few individuals nonetheless prefer it, some individuals don’t — is a type of resonance known as stochastic resonance, wherein an present sign is being boosted. It’s a sign increase. Binaural listening to itself is described that manner; it’s known as the cocktail social gathering impact. Oster talked about that in his article, the place you may have all that noise and someway it doesn’t drown out the sound location, it enhances it. And all of the research authors and their conclusion once they’re describing what occurs, that’s what they’re describing. Background noise doesn’t drown out binaural beats, it enhances it. It’s essential hear them. Oster measured a binaural beat to be roughly three dB’s, like a whisper. You don’t want to listen to that whisper for it to have an effect on you. Essentially the most have an effect on they’ve discovered is with pink noise. So you possibly can throw some pink noise in your recording. You in all probability don’t have to listen to that both.

John: Effectively, you understand, in our stuff you don’t hear the bada bada bada or no matter it’s, it’s received all this different lovely stuff that’s layered over it. And there it’s. That is nice. We’ve recognized all these things for a very long time, however that is terrific. Thanks.

Elizabeth: I sort of like electronica; I just like the binaural beats with like a chill electronica observe, or it could possibly be with lovely guitar music, or it could possibly be nature sounds. That’s my desire. However within the research, it exhibits that pink noise causes the very best impact — not that the others don’t. Very clear. Many individuals had impact with all of the others. Some used it as a pure tone — I wouldn’t discover that very nice to hearken to for any period of time. However then once more, you need to keep in mind who’s creating these assessments, neuroscientists.

John: That’s a very good level.

Elizabeth: Well being professionals, cognitive psychologists. They’re not within the area of sound.

Doug: One of many packages that I’ve completed for iAwake — most of them, anyway — I embody a low quantity mattress of pink noise, which I then frequency elevate as nicely. I’ve discovered N=1 with this, however discovered that it enhances the results for me.

Elizabeth: Okay, fabulous validation proper there. And that’s backed by the scientific information.

Doug: Great to listen to.

Elizabeth: For certain. The protocol: So, if it is a sign booster or sign enhancer, what’s it enhancing? It means it’s enhancing a preexisting one thing. Right here’s a research that I discovered that’s not binaural beats. In a mouse, they discovered when the mouse skilled concern, unexpectedly a mind wave that related the frontal cortex and the amygdala at 4 Hz. How cool is that? However we’re beginning to perceive that the mind is speaking in these mind waves, in these neural, electrical, rhythmic indicators...4 Hz, 4 Hz, 4 Hz, 4 Hz. That’s concern in a mouse. Let’s simply put that over there for a second. So again to the binaural beats, what are these beats coming in and amplifying? I’ve one research the place they really created nervousness and concern with a 6 Hz binaural beat. What!? So we’ve lots of variables right here. You want a really refined evaluation and diagnostic to grasp all of the transferring items. It’s like we’re beginning to see items right here and there. One research makes use of synthetic intelligence, multi-layer perceptron, it’s known as, to research their EEG information. It’s a false, a man-made nervous system, a computer-generated nervous system, that’s good sufficient to interpret a number of layers of transferring information. As a result of in a very good scientific experiment, you need to scale back the information. You solely must have just a few variables to be able to see what’s affecting what.

Elizabeth: What occurs when you’ve got 18 variables? You find yourself with one research the place you might be scary concern and one research the place you might be creating peace. I’ve one research I believed actually addressed this, and it’s a research of 109 contributors, so it’s strong. The writer is Sabo, Hungarian, and so they have been testing for trance and meditation. They discovered that they have been capable of induce a trance-like state of their 109 topics, however provided that that they had a protocol of rest given to them earlier than the observe. So when you have individuals which can be utilizing your binaural beats, they might naturally be doing this. “Okay, that is my time, I’m going to take a seat down, I’m going to hearken to my beats…” They might set an intention unconsciously. “I’m going to chill out now.”

Elizabeth: Effectively all these issues, what if these are the indicators that you’re amplifying? Proper? Such as you create your individual set of mind waves. And so there’s one other factor to substantiate this, along with this one scientific research, and that’s Atwater himself on the Monroe Institute. So the Monroe Institute, which you all know what it’s, was so profitable utilizing binaural beats synergistically of their program to create profound states of meditation and astral projection and enlargement of consciousness and therapeutic in that manner — and so they at all times had a protocol. It could possibly be verbalizing to your self, it could possibly be deep respiration, it could possibly be emotional, like HeartMath, imagining lovely locations…You possibly can even have that in your observe. “We’re going to take two minutes now and put together for this observe. Think about your favourite place on this planet. Name your favourite emotion into your coronary heart. Is it love? Is it gratitude? Is it awe?” One thing like that will be acceptable for a meditation observe. For a spotlight observe, I’d do one thing totally different.

Elizabeth: So one of many points we’ve within the area is that nothing is standardized. That’s certainly one of my huge suggestions. I would not have for you information that claims this research used this, and this research used this, and this research used this. Most of them don’t even report whether or not they used it or not. However I do have that one research that was conclusive with 109 topics and Atwater and the Monroe Institute which have been doing this for 50 years. For me, that’s fairly clear that the protocol is de facto necessary and a giant issue. A few of these research, you set somebody in a lab chair, they’re simply sitting there. It’s like, “Take heed to this.” “Okay!” What are you undertaking? And but they’re nonetheless getting some information, however my level is, have you ever even reached any of the impact potential of this? You’ve been capable of show that it exists beneath these sterile scientific circumstances, however have you ever truly reached the impact potential?

John: You realize, it would clarify why lots of us who use this know-how have been meditators earlier than we began utilizing the know-how, and this simply took us into the deep aspect of the pool in a short time. And I’ve observed over time that skilled meditators get it straight away. They go, wow, that is truly doing one thing.

Elizabeth: Oh, that makes a lot sense.

Doug: I’ve been engaged on a lucid dreaming program for fairly a while now that makes use of binaural beats and another applied sciences, and a part of the explanation it’s taken me so lengthy is getting the instructing materials and the protocol down, as a result of that’s a crucial element of this. The know-how by itself is beautiful, however it’s what you do beforehand and the way you employ it that makes all of the distinction within the success.

Elizabeth: So, you might be discovering that in your subjective expertise, in your case research, if you’ll.

Doug: Proper — that having the right method and realizing what to do makes all of the distinction in whether or not or not you get the results that I’m intending from it.

John: Sure, and most of the people appear to report that once they begin utilizing the know-how, their sleep and dream life change into very lively and far more vibrant, far more highly effective. Do you’ve got something that will clarify why that’s so?

Elizabeth: I’d level you to that research and also you would want any person that would perceive…So every sleep cycle he calls them, one, two, and three, they’ve particular designations, and he’s capable of research how binaural beats lengthens or shortens your totally different sleep levels. So if there’s a dream sleep stage that binaural beats are enhancing and lengthening, that will be your reply. However I don’t have sufficient information to conclusively reply that, simply to type of level in that path and say, there’s a scientific research exhibiting which sleep levels the binaural beats have an effect on. And that research was a conclusively constructive impact for the contributors. They used EEG for the mind exercise, for the attention exercise, for muscle exercise, and so they used a BRUMS, a temper questionnaire. In order that was the diagnostics there. It was a fairly conclusive research.

Modeling binaural beats after the goal wave form

Doug: A query that I needed to ask, and this goes in a barely totally different path right here, however you have been speaking earlier about rhythm and the significance of rhythm and what a giant distinction that makes. I puzzled, nicely, one thing you stated in your presentation actually perked my ears up, because it have been, which is, you stated mind waves and the patterns of mind waves, the form of an alpha wave on the EEG or a theta wave or a delta wave, these should not sine waves. And what would occur if we began creating tracks the place the binaural beats have been modeled after the form of the waves that they’re focusing on? So I’ve been utilizing a wave desk synthesizer the place I can draw within the wave kind, the sample of the tone, and create some fairly attention-grabbing sounds based mostly on what I’ve drawn there. And if I have been to focus on a specific brainwave state, take an EEG studying of what it’s that I’m focusing on and use that to create the sound, would which have any impact on its means to assist the mind attain these focused states?

Elizabeth: That’s fairly deep. You’re in there deep! One of many shows I simply listened to was any person exploring an identical concept to yours. They have been drawing the totally different shapes of their waves and undertaking various things with them, although I don’t assume it was binaural beats. I believe it was simply frequency therapeutic. So the factor that involves me so as to add to that inquiry is that resonant frequency is measurable, and in case you are focusing on a resonant frequency and sending vitality to that resonant frequency, you’d create an amplification of obtainable vitality. Might we use that vitality for therapeutic? That might be both your research of your contributors or within the lab, we must discover out.

How resonance creates further vitality for the mind

Elizabeth: Let me clarify what I used to be saying there. With entrainment, a stronger wave entrains a much less robust wave. The amplification can solely elevate so far as the stronger wave, however there’s an vitality enhance there. So right here’s how I discovered to consider this. My definitions all got here from the physics world and I put them along with the definitions within the sound world. Your physique, as a way to survive, have to be as environment friendly with its vitality utilization as attainable. I learn lots of Michael Thaut, an incredible pioneer within the music remedy world and neurologic music remedy world, a giant title — positively Google him. What he helped me to grasp is that the mind has a rhythm and a tempo. If you’re sending music to the mind, you’re sending music within the language that the mind speaks. That’s the structure of the mind. So lovely, his work.

Elizabeth: After which, to get again to the opposite level, so while you’re entraining — or resonating — you might be creating obtainable vitality. Now the physique desires to be environment friendly with its vitality, so that you’re speaking to the mind in its language and also you’re saying, “vitality obtainable right here, vitality obtainable right here.” So everyone will say, “Oh, I need a constant frequency. Constant frequency is wholesome. The mind must be in a constant frequency.” That’s truly not true within the work of thought. I learn that. Your mind is chaos (laughs), and so consistency will be good at occasions, however at occasions it’s an excessive amount of. That’s how they diagnose autism or a few of these different problems, when it’s too constant. We are able to’t be too constant in some circumstances. So, listed below are all these vitality patterns and waves going round. And I believe the purpose that I’m attempting to make is you need to have the correct quantity of vitality obtainable on the proper time for the correct factor for the mind to function effectively and be blissful. For those who’re utilizing entrainment, you’re going to get a bit bump of vitality.

Elizabeth: Why would the mind use that? Why would the mind need a bit bump of vitality? What would that be good for? For utilizing resonance, okay? Resonance is a distinct mechanism. Resonance is sort of limitless vitality coming in, and you may break that threshold. That’s the opera singer singing into the glass: the opera singer discovered the resonant frequency of the glass, pumped a lot vitality into that equation that that system stated, okay, we’ve to blow up now. That’s why the glass breaks. I had an atomic physicist on my committee. I needed to. You possibly can’t discuss sound with no physicist. He helped me to grasp this.

Elizabeth: So, what does the mind want? What is going to make the mind environment friendly in that type of scenario? For those who’re making a resonant frequency…these are measurable, by the best way. These issues are measurable. That might be an enormous enlargement in vibrational drugs when docs and hospitals working along with physicists will begin to have the ability to measure the resonant frequency. They do it for ultrasound, for kidney stones. That’s an ultrasound coming in, blowing up the tumor by increasing the vitality handed what the tumor can deal with. So, you’re sort of speaking a couple of resonance impact creating that vitality there. And what I actually wish to know is, how can we are saying for certain that vitality is turning into obtainable for therapeutic? How can we are saying for certain that the mind goes to say, that’s environment friendly for me, I’m going to make use of it?

Elizabeth: We all know that constant vitality is environment friendly vitality. That’s why we’ve coupled oscillation, that’s why nerve cells come collectively. That’s why your coronary heart beats like that each one collectively. That’s environment friendly. That’s why pendulums, in the event that they get shut sufficient, will come collectively. Pendulums is how we began finding out this, and it creates that vitality effectivity. So these are type of the parameters that we’re coping with right here. So sound remedy says, nicely, constant vitality is environment friendly and in lots of circumstances it’s. Sound vitality says, okay, let’s use inconsistent, jagged tones to interrupt up vitality, to interrupt up caught vitality. In Michael Thaut’s book it exhibits when you have to be taught one thing new and shock the mind, that’s the mechanism. The mind will hold doing what it does as a result of it’s environment friendly till you shock it. So it could use that to create a brand new sample, a brand new program, a brand new studying. So these are a few of the ways in which these sounds and vitality mechanisms work, and so I give that to you since you’re sort of in there working with how a lot vitality do I create? That’s what you’re doing, you’re creating. It’s actually thrilling. I wish to hear.

John: Oh, it’s best to.

Doug: So many attention-grabbing ideas and concepts that come simply from that.

John: Effectively, the excellent news is technically the elevator received caught between the twelfth and thirteenth flooring. So, yeah, right here we’re. That was a simple interview! Pull the string. Very, very, very helpful.

Heidi: Okay, simply to return to the very starting, so if any person says, oh, I hear that really with brainwave entrainment, the entrainment phrase is fallacious. It’s not entraining. Is it simply…what’s it doing once more within the quick model? Like for those who hearken to iAwake?

Elizabeth: Frequency following response.

Heidi: After which that reinforces vitality and creates a resonance?

Elizabeth: A stochastic resonance, yeah, it’s a sign increase. Power turns into obtainable…can we use it for therapeutic? I believe that’s what we’re doing.

Heidi: Proper.

Binaural beats synchronize your mind hemispheres. 

Elizabeth: There’s one thing else actually necessary, binaural beats do one thing else. So it’s a frequency following response that reinforces indicators and synchronizes your mind hemispheres, which is so highly effective. We’re on the frontier of that and we’ve some established modalities, not solely neurologic music remedy however EMDR. We’re bilateral! Very highly effective issues occur once we synchronize our two sides.

Heidi: Yeah, that’s superior.

John: Elizabeth, I’d like to ask you if attainable — give us a bit to digest all of this, evaluate my notes, and make a transcription, and I wish to ship, clearly, this interview to all our creators as a result of there’s a lot useful stuff right here, and make it obtainable to the general public. You’re simply such a a very good, clear speaker and instantly my graduate scholar kicked in and I began taking copious notes of every thing you’re saying, as a result of it was like all necessary and also you simply triggered some frequency in my mind to take notes.

Elizabeth: We have been on the identical frequency. (laughs)

John: That is so thrilling and so encouraging, and sure, might we’ve you again a while if we might persuade you or one thing? I’d additionally wish to get you into the world of the conferences that I am going to, the Integral world. You realize, there’s a convention I am going to yearly — nicely, earlier than the pandemic — however we hope to get again there in Hungary. It brings lots of the Integral takes to the world collectively. It’s an amazing expertise. It will be very helpful as a result of we’ve been speaking about these things for a very long time, however you’ve got simply put all of it along with the science and superior the sphere considerably. Deep bow, and thanks for that.

Elizabeth: It was grueling, thrilling, enjoyable, lengthy, (laughs) and so rewarding. Thanks. You realize, after 4 years of sitting at your desk, it’s good to come back out and discuss to individuals about it.

John: Oh, I wager. Effectively, welcome again. Thanks.

Mixing frequencies works finest.

Doug: By blended frequencies, do you imply layered binaural beats at totally different entrainment charges?

Elizabeth: Like placing theta and alpha collectively to your meditations and beta and gamma collectively to your focusing.

John: Epsilon can be an instance of that too, Doug?

Doug: Effectively, it could be blended with one thing. So, yeah, for those who combine… Like in Stealing Flow, it’s primarily on the alpha/theta border, but additionally with gamma layered in on prime of it for the mixed impact.

Heidi: Or the deep releasing meditations which can be theta, however then with bits of gamma to make issues occur inside…

Elizabeth: Wait a minute, did you do this intuitively?

Doug: The theta and gamma? I learn this excellent e book, Stealing Fire, and I learn Csikszentmihalyi’s book about stream…

Elizabeth: I beloved that e book, too! (laughs)

Elizabeth: Very cool. In one of many shows I simply watched, theta was carrying…so right here’s the theta sine wave carrying all these little gamma waves on it, like on a whale’s again, little barnacles throughout the mind. Cool, huh? Yeah, that’s an amazing instance.

John: Doug, I simply had an concept, possibly take a few of your works and simply ship them to Elizabeth with the notes of what you truly did and the way you probably did that. May be actually…

Doug: It’d be fascinating.

Elizabeth: Yeah. I don’t know, I simply make them from my music. I’ve launched eight albums, you understand, I’m all about sound, each facet of it, creating it, finding out it, every thing. And on my final one I put some binaural beats in, and I’ve a query for you. So I discovered that I like two beats collectively, and I discover that I even like three collectively, however 4 was an excessive amount of for me. Three was my restrict. After that, I used to be like, that’s an excessive amount of data.

Doug: Yeah.

Elizabeth: You will have any of that dialog occurring?

Doug: The one time I’ve appreciated 4 is in a re-creation of the Awakened Mind pattern.

Elizabeth: Oooh, yeah, the Thoughts Map?

Doug: With Anna Clever, yeah. Recreating that, getting 4 in there works nicely, however past that I haven’t experimented with it an excessive amount of, greater than doing two or so at a time.

Elizabeth: Maintain me posted!

John: You realize, as a musician myself, I play lead guitar, and when there’s a bass and a drum in sync, you understand, like Fleetwood Mac, by way of all its permutations and all the nice music that band has created, that they had an amazing bass participant and an amazing drummer. You realize, all the opposite characters modified, I believe, for essentially the most half. However when that bass factor is laid down, that offers the individuals on prime an unbelievable artistic house to play in, and I can simply really feel it waking me up. I don’t know what that’s. You realize, it’s music, it’s magic, however it could be attention-grabbing simply to.. You realize, why does that occur?

John: Wow. That’s proper.

Elizabeth: However that’s what’s occurring in right here. We’re all ratios — all of the planets, all of the cells, every thing is ratios. And you’ll describe that with music and arithmetic.

John: So we didn’t invent math and music, we’re discovering it as we go.

Elizabeth: We discerned it.

John: Yeah, we discerned it. There you go. Superior. Anyway, we’re very enthusiastic about this. I by no means know what to anticipate, so I don’t anticipate something, however that is… I can’t say it exceeded my expectations as a result of I didn’t have any, however I’m very, very blissful and really impressed and really enlightened by this dialog. And we’d like to have you ever again as soon as we digest this, have just a few extra questions, and possibly we will throw in a few of our stuff, too, and simply construct the dialog.

Elizabeth: I sit up for it. As you may see, that is… It was my dissertation, and that’s sufficiently big, however it’s additionally my life path. So sure, I’m at all times on it.

John: I really feel that. Sure, okay, thanks a lot. We respect you a large number.

Heidi: Yeah, that was great.

John: Thanks, Doug, thanks, Heidi.

Elizabeth: Doug, thanks.

Doug: Thanks a lot.

Elizabeth: Thanks Heidi.

Heidi: Thanks. Hope to see you once more. All proper, and good luck along with your additional endeavors.

John: Okay, bye bye.

---

Learn Dr. Krasnoff’s printed 2021 dissertation “The Effects of Auditory Binaural Beats on Consciousness and the Human Nervous System” here.

---

Focus with gamma, do your emotional work and visioning with theta, assist your sleep patterns with delta…iAwake Applied sciences might help you entry these brainwave states and extra…epsilon and lambda for instance!

---

---

---

---

---